| Division Two | |||
| 06/09/2003 | Hepworth Utd | 2 - 1 | New Mill 94 |
| 13/09/2003 | New Mill 94 | 1 - 1 | Lepton Highlanders |
| 20/09/2003 | Mount | 2 - 4 | New Mill 94 |
| 27/09/2003 | New Mill 94 | 0 - 2 | Newsome WMC |
| 04/10/2003 | Lindley Liberal | 1 - 1 | New Mill 94 |
| 11/10/2003 | New Mill 94 | 2 - 1 | Mount |
| FA Challenge Cup Round One | |||
| 18/10/2003 | The Stag FC | 1 - 3 | New Mill 94 |
| 25/10/2003 | Scissett | 0 - 1 | New Mill 94 |
| 01/11/2003 | New Mill 94 | 3 - 2 | Netherton |
| Barlow Cup Round One | |||
| 08/11/2003 | Uppermill | 2 - 0 | New Mill 94 |
| FA Challenge Cup Round Two | |||
| 15/11/2003 | New Mill 94 | 3 - 5 | Syngenta (WL) |
| 22/11/2003 | New Mill 94 | 2 - 7 | Uppermill |
| 29/11/2003 | Sovereign Sports | 1 - 4 | New Mill 94 |
| 06/12/2003 | New Mill 94 | 2 - 3 | Moldgreen |
| 13/12/2003 | New Mill 94 | 3 - 3 | Sovereign Sports |
| 03/01/2004 | Moldgreen | P - P | New Mill 94 |
| 10/01/2004 | Netherton | 0 - 1 | New Mill 94 |
| 17/01/2004 | New Mill 94 | 6 - 0 | Scissett |
| 24/01/2004 | New Mill 94 | 2 - 0 | Storthes Hall |
| 31/01/2004 | Newsome WMC | 2 - 2 | New Mill 94 |
| 07/02/2004 | New Mill 94 | 3 - 2 | Lindley Liberal |
| 14/02/2004 | Lepton Highlanders | 2 - 2 | New Mill 94 |
| 21/02/2004 | Uppermill | 2 - 2 | New Mill 94 |
| 06/03/2004 | New Mill 94 | 3 - 2 | Hepworth Utd |
| 13/03/2004 | Storthes Hall | 0 - 1 | New Mill 94 |